A consistent demand of students is for less importance to be given to the traditional end-of-session examination which, however carefully set, is heavily biased in favour of students with good memory, instant recall and psychic powers of spotting questions. A partial solution to the problem of student assessment is the assignment carried out in the student's own time. A problem was used which any real physicist, whether researcher or teacher, might have to carry out: to examine a physical paper closely, to check its accuracy and the accuracy of its references by use of the library, and to apply it to answer some questions. With this as a framework the students are asked for expressions of opinion. Classical papers have been used since modern papers usually require too much background knowledge. They lend themselves to the type of question which asks the student to interpret the classical results in terms of the modern knowledge he is beginning to acquire.