We consider the growth of rigid, non-branching polymers nucleated from a planar surface. In contrast to DLA models, the present theory includes effects of both a finite concentration of monomers and reversibility of the growth. In addition, we consider an assembly/disassembly process that is accompanied by reduction of the monomers' ability to repolymerize, which we call monomer degradation. The analysis of mean-field equations and numerical simulations both lead to scaling solutions for reversible as well as irreversible growth. For instance, we find that (in the absence of monomer degradation) a diffusive scaling regime, typical for DLA-like problems, can be defined that crosses over to a linear scaling regime at a time-dependent length scale. In the presence of monomer degradation, however, the diffusive regime disappears and an array with constant polymer density grows linearly in time. This unusual behavior is due to a depletion of monomers that allows only a finite subpopulation of polymers to "escape", leaving all other polymers growing and shrinking in the vicinity of the nucleating surface.