For the last six years, Measurement Science and
Technology has awarded a Best Paper prize. The Editorial
Board of the journal believes that awarding such a prize is an
opportunity to say `thank you' to authors for submitting their
best material, and serves as a focus for their on-going quality
review.
The working party, composed of R J Dewhurst, P P L Regtien and
M A Player, considered a large number of papers recommended by Board
Members. We would like to thank Board Members for their
responses that formed an important part of the assessment
process. We drew up a short-list
of nine papers from the Board Member responses we received.
We re-examined these papers, with a view to finding an original
contributed paper that described new and significant work, and that
was presented in a clear and rigorous way. We also considered
the referee-assigned quality ratings of the papers, and the number of
accesses made to the papers in the Electronic Journal. We specifically
excluded review papers, or papers appearing in special
issues or special features that were of a review nature.
After lengthy discussions, we present the 1999 Best Paper Award
to the following paper:
J Krupka, K Derzakowski, M Tobar, J Hartnett and
R G Geyer Complex permittivity of some ultralow loss dielectric
crystals at cryogenic temperatures10 387-92 (published
May 1999)
The award, comprising a cash honorarium and plaque, will be
presented to the author at a suitable venue in the near future.
The paper describes the measurement science and technology
required to conduct measurements of permittivity and the dielectric
loss tangent in low-loss crystals down to 4 K. It provides a
clear description of the techniques used. The quality of the data,
together with comparison of values from previous published work,
vindicates their measurement claims. The results presented
establish a very accurate (with 0.1% tolerance) permittivity
versus temperature database for a number of low-loss crystals,
e.g. sapphire, YAG, quartz and SrLaAlO4, in the 10-20 GHz region.
Tan δ measurements down to 10-8 are presented. In addition,
the paper contains a solid set of references and draws together
a concise set of conclusions as a summary.
We also short-listed a further three papers for the award:
T Schmitz and J Ziegert A new sensor for
the micrometer-level measurement of three-dimensional, dynamic
contours10 51-62 (published February 1999)
M Höbel and K Haffner An on-line monitoring system for oil-film, pressure and
temperature distributions in
large-scale hydro-generator bearings10 393-402 (published May 1999)
S Yokoyama, J Ohnishi, S Iwasaki, K
Seta, H Matsumoto and N Suzuki Real-time and
high-resolution absolute-distance measurement using a
two-wavelength superheterodyne interferometer10 1233-9 (published December 1999)