Having approached this book with eager expectation, I have to
admit I was soon disappointed. Firstly, it seems to me that the
title is rather misleading: how many would think of `Analog
Electrical Devices & Measurements' - Chapter 6; `Sampling,
Digital Devices & Data Acquisition' - Chapter 7, or `Temperature
Measurements' - Chapter 8, as Mechanical measurements? This
aside, however, I find the coverage both patchy and uneven; there
are some excellent and useful sections, obviously those where the
authors have personal experience, such as for instance Chapter 11,
`Strain Measurements', and also some useful work on Probability
and Statistics and Uncertainty Analysis, but the appreciation of a
problem is often too superficial, with many sources of error being
overlooked or ignored.
However, the most serious problem with the book is the number
of errors, some of such a fundamental nature that one is inevitably
driven to consider just how much of the rest one can consider reliable.
Some instances will show what one must expect. These examples
were not found by a careful trawl in depth, so must be considered
as representative only.
The definition of the ohm as the resistance of a column of
mercury was abandoned many years ago; a standard cell must never be used to deliver 100 mA, let alone for a few minutes,
and in any case, both volt and ohm have been defined for more
than ten years by quantum effects.
Problem 1.37 specifies an LVDT being driven by a d.c. voltage,
when of course only a.c. can be used. (There are `d.c.' LVDTs
but these contain electronics to generate the necessary a.c.) The
accompanying diagram also shows the connections incorrectly and
the text contains the sentence `outputs a voltage which is linear to
the input'. Which input? The electrical one or the displacement?
Such looseness abounds, even ignoring the use of `output' as a verb.
Page 36:
`Analog describes a signal that is continuous in time'.
Alas, not so, analog describes a signal where the intelligence is
represented by a continuously variable level.
Page 43: Fig. 2.8 seems to show (quite clearly!) that
subtracting a d.c. offset actually causes a waveform to change shape.
Page 197:
`An a.c. meter indicates a true rms value for a simple
periodic signal only'. Absolutely wrong: an a.c. meter (the
rectified moving coil type is meant) indicates average only,
whatever it may be scaled.
The authors' application of mathematical analysis to the
consideration of errors is both praiseworthy and necessary but
reveals their obvious preference for an analysis of errors rather
than for the application of careful thought to remove sources of
error first, before applying analysis to those that inevitably
remain. An example of this lack of thought is revealed in Fig. 6.4,
a simple multirange ammeter, where the moving coil would
vaporize if the switch were ever operated under load or there were
ever any jump in contact resistance. Amazingly there is no
discussion of the universal shunt, nor of the necessity of a
swamping series resistor.
There is very little discussion of what most people would actually
think of when considering `Mechanical Measurement'.
Importantly, there is no discussion on the fundamental and vital
differences between a micrometer and a caliper - that the former
indicates its own true zero, unless it is very seriously damaged,
while the latter is subject to many errors caused by wear or by
quite minor damage, a further indication of inattention to some
vital considerations. The authors seem also to be unaware that
micrometers can be used in at least as large a size as a caliper.
There is no mention at all of modern precision coordinate
measuring machines - only one of several omissions.
The arrangement of the knife edges of a precision balance in Fig. 12.13,
purporting to show a precision balance, is drastically wrong.
A pencil type pressure gauge has no spring, which rather makes
nonsense of the rest of the analysis.
It is surprising and regrettable that so many errors (and there are
many more) should have survived into a third edition. A major
revision is called for before the book could be wholeheartedly
recommended.
This book is certainly a useful addition to one's library for its
chapters on probability of statistics and analysis on uncertainty,
but it would be most unwise to use it for general guidance on
the theory of measurements for one not already thoroughly familiar
with the design of actual instruments.
J C Taylor