For the last eleven years, Measurement Science and
Technology has awarded
a Best Paper prize. The Editorial Board of the journal believes that such a
prize is an opportunity to thank authors for submitting their work, and
serves as an integral part of the on-going quality review of the journal.
An Editorial Board working party, comprising Patrick Gill (Chairman),
Ralph Tatam and David Birch, was convened to determine a single
contributed paper describing new and significant work, well aligned with
the measurement scope of the journal, and presented in clear and rigorous
form. They received a number of recommendations from the Editorial and
International Advisory Board Members, and they would like to record
their thanks to the Members for these recommendations, as they form an
all-important first stage in the assessment process. There were responses
from some six Board Members, together with a number of inputs from the
science community. In total, there were 15 papers nominated. To aid the
process, additional information in the form of the 2000 MST papers top
rated by referees, and the top papers ranked by most electronic accesses,
was accessed. Reviews, and papers which included a Board Member as an
author, were automatically excluded. From the totality of nominations and
working party deliberations, there emerged a clear winner.
Thus the paper recommended by the working party for the MST Best
Paper Award for 2002 is:
This paper describes a new type of voltage probe for monitoring human
body electrical activity. Conventional ECG probes for heart and brain
activity use a series of electrodes with 1-10 MΩ input impedance in
contact with the skin. These are invasive in that they distort the surface
potentials induced by body currents. Efforts to overcome this have led to
research into SQUID probes capable of operating a few centimetres from
the body, but these of course require cryogenic operation. This paper
reports the development of an ultra-high-impedance
(10
15 Ω), ultra-low-noise
probe capable of operating at room temperature. In addition, the
probe is capable of non-contact operation at distance up to 1 m from the
body. The combination of this remote operation and ultra-high impedance
leads to a non-invasive arrangement, and the ultra-low-noise operation
leads to an ability to detect very small currents. This is extremely
powerful in its potential to detect weak electrical activity from a variety of
sources within the human body.
The paper is well structured with a good outline of the background to the
work, a clear description of the device, followed by a range of
measurement data showing the non-contact signals achievable. The
capability of the device is compared with other more conventional
techniques. The authors point to the potential for high resolution body
mapping techniques with arrays of such probes. The concept is highly
innovative, and topical, and could have very significant implications for
health monitoring in the future. Its significance has been demonstrated
very clearly through the largest number of electronic downloads of the
article in the 2002 issues of MST, way in excess of the next most popular
paper. The paper is well written in a way to appeal to a large cross-section
of the readership and a wider audience. We had no hesitation in
recommending this paper for the MST Best Paper Award for 2002.