The articles in this special feature of Measurement Science and Technology are devoted to an exciting area of fluid metrology pursuing the registration of flow velocities in three dimensions by particle
holography—commonly termed holographic particle image velocimetry (HPIV) (Hinsch 2002).
Already in 1993 this technique was considered to 'revolutionize the acquisition of velocity data in
much the same way as did the inventions of hot wire anemometry and laser Doppler velocimetry' as
E P Rood states in his foreword to the proceedings of the first workshop dedicated to the topic at the
Washington ASME Fluid Engineering Conference (Rood 1993). The big step forward is to eliminate most
of the depth-of-focus restrictions of classical PIV by a holographic recording of tracer particles. Thus,
even non-stationary flows can be registered in a single record.
A central concern of the early days was to explore optical set-ups suitable for improving particle-position
resolution by using large recording apertures and for suppressing coherent noise. Furthermore, the evaluation of the holographic images required efficient hardware and software to scan and process the coordinates
of particle images in a reasonable time. A sophisticated system relying on the state-of-the art experience
and the utmost in processing hardware was producing first fields of thousands of three-dimensional
velocity vectors (Barnhart et al 1994). Much profound research work on the main issues has been carried
out in the meantime. Advances toward practical systems, however, needed fuelling by the recent
technological developments of high-energy pulsed lasers and electronic image acquisition as well as
the increasing performance of digital image processing.
This recent progress led to a session on HPIV during the international PIV'01 conference at
Göttingen, Germany (Kompenhans 2001), the creation of a worldwide working group
(photon.physik.uni-oldenburg.de/hpiv)
and in May 2003 an international workshop on
holographic metrology in fluid mechanics at Loughborough University, UK (Coupland
2003). These workshop presentations have been elaborated
and supplemented in the present special feature.
The holographic velocimetry work presented here can be grouped into two sections according to the type
of hologram recording—using either a physical carrier material or an electronic image sensor. Most
researchers still use the somewhat anachronistic silver-halide emulsion of photographic film,
especially when high resolving power is needed as in several application-specific topics. It offers still
an unequalled resolution of up to 5000 line-pairs/mm at reasonable sensitivities to record even the
low-power light scattered by tiny tracer particles, yet it requires laborious wet chemical processing.
A good impression of the huge amount of data that can be stored on photographic film and the
immense effort needed to analyse the reconstructed holographic images is given in the paper by E Malkiel et al. A straightforward in-line recording layout was chosen for the submersible recording system employed in marine studies. An efficient analysis of hundreds of holograms is achieved with an
automated scanning system incorporating an optical band-pass filter to suppress speckle noise and to
detect small tracer particles even in the neighbourhood of much larger `particles' like copepods that
are screened by a segmentation routine. Data flow is economized by a new and highly efficient
compression method.
While the disturbing effect of speckle noise is much relaxed in the widely used off-axis recording it
still has a considerable impact when large and densely seeded volumes are under investigation. Light-in-flight holography (LiFH)—a way to suppress noise by coherence reduction—is applied to a large wind-tunnel flow in the paper by S F Herrmann and K D Hinsch. While a complete deep-volume field is recorded,
the effective depth during the read-out process can be reduced to avoid noise from too many
out-of-focus particle images. Analysis of the digitized real-image particle field is done by direct 3D correlation of grey-values from depth-scans. Based on the same experimental data a paper by K Hinsch and S F Herrmann explores in detail the gain in signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) for digitized image planes and describes the performance of LiFH versus normal holography based on speckle theory.
Reconstruction from a double-exposure hologram permits direct correlation of the complex amplitude of the particle fields locally in a method called object conjugate reconstruction (OCR), which is presented in a new configuration (transmission) in the paper by R Alcock et al. The technique is ideally suited to measuring within thick glass cylinders (engine research) because it dispenses with the need to correct for distortions by use of holographic optical elements. Instead, a ray tracing analysis is used for correct mapping.
Holographers have tested many alternative materials to avoid the time delay and effort in processing
standard photographic film, all of which still show at least a major disadvantage in resolution,
sensitivity or handling. More recently a genetically modified version of the photochromic protein
bacteriorhodopsin (BR) has been introduced to HPIV measurements. It offers perfect resolution and
sufficient optical sensitivity and is examined extensively here. D Barnhart et al explain BR's basic properties and propose a variety of new configurations, also utilizing its ability to alter the state of
polarization in the reconstruction. Though the storage time of BR holograms is limited to a few
minutes when the same wavelength is used for readout, V S S Chan et al have realized a first application of double-exposure HPIV. They also introduce further concepts to achieve multiple holograms in BR. In conclusion, BR is considered the most promising candidate to replace silver-halide photographic
film, and also for intermediate storage of holograms to be scanned and processed digitally.
Two of our papers consider holographic tools for tasks in fluid dynamics other than velocimetry. I Shimizu et al are concerned with the discrimination of size and shape from arbitrarily positioned particles by reviving a historical concept of multiplexed matched spatial filtering in which a special type of hologram is used for pattern recognition purposes. Automated in-place processing is achieved with photoconductor plastic holograms (PPH). Holographic interferometry is used by S-J Lee and S Kim in the study of quasi-two-dimensional Hele–Schaw convection to visualize temperature distributions. The results are compared with those obtained from velocity mapping by conventional PIV.
The second half of our contributions are dedicated to the challenge of performing particle holography
digitally. This reflects the need to overcome the essential bottlenecks of classical particle holography:
the time delay and cumbersome processing by photographic recording, the difficulty of recording time
series and the experimental effort needed to extract particle coordinates in three dimensions—these
are severe obstacles on the way towards a tool of general practical applicability. For an estimate of its
potential, recall the breakthrough of 2D PIV when it turned from photographic to CCD recording!
A digital hologram that consists of an array of intensity values stored in a computer memory, of
course, does not provide the beauty of viewing a live reconstructed three-dimensional image.
However, this is not the aim of particle holography, since the end data—coordinate values and
displacements for a large number of particles—must be extracted laboriously from the reconstructed
real images of the particle field anyway. We don't need the physical wave reconstruction and might
just as well represent it by appropriate computer routines. Yet, the performance of typical
CCD sensors still falls short of that of photographic film. Any holographic set-up must take into account
that, due to the size and number of pixels, resolution in the hologram is less by a factor of about 10 and the number of resolvable elements less by a factor of 10000. This imposes restrictions on interference angles and field width—a challenge to the creativity of researchers, who each propose specific solutions.
Two papers address the problem of inferior longitudinal resolution in completely digital HPIV caused
by the small CCD aperture. H Meng et al obtain a greatly improved depth discrimination by the
utilization of phase information in the particle image field—data that are specific for digital
reconstruction and not available in the commonly used intensity fields. The vector plot of results from
a water jet flow illustrates the state-of-the-art of the technique and can stand comparison with
traditional results. This paper may also be considered a good introduction to the topic, a
comprehensive overview of HPIV systems operated worldwide and a summary of the critical issues in
digital particle holography. C Fournier et al observe axial oscillations of particle image intensity that impede focus finding and are remedied by proper aperture windowing.
The CCD problem is avoided when traditional recording is accepted and only the reconstruction is
done digitally—as shown in the paper by H Yang et al. The lengthy scanning and correlation of 3D image fields is now replaced by 2D high-resolution digitization of intermediate holograms on 35 mm film
and complex correlation operating with these data. In the presentation by M Malek et al
three-dimensionality is confined to space while velocity is restricted to two components. Particle
displacements within a set of transverse planes are then obtained by conventional particle tracking
algorithms. J Müller et al show in their application-oriented study of the atomization of molten metal that a CCD-based in-line hologram with resolution improved by relay imaging provides satisfactory data for the numerical reconstruction of particle location and size.
J Coupland presents some thought-provoking ideas to tackle under-sampling by the widely spaced
CCD pixels. When the optical field of a particle image is known, model fitting can compensate for the
loss of information. Additionally, annoying replicas of particle images may be avoided by a
non-periodic array of sampling apertures. Finally, J Lobera et al explore a different version of holography for PIV applications, i.e. digital speckle pattern interferometry (DSPI), a technique well established for deformation contouring in optical metrology. Here, image plane holograms of single planes in the fluid flow map particle displacements with interferometric sensitivity—a means to greatly improve
depth resolution.
We are convinced that our collection of papers is a comprehensive presentation of the state-of-the-art
in this innovative field of fluid metrology. It serves to further exchange between the research groups
involved and should inform and stimulate those looking for non-conventional solutions to their
metrological challenges.
The editors appreciate very much the stimulating cooperation with the staff
of Measurement Science and Technology, especially with
S D'Souza-Harris, the cooperative assistance of our writing colleagues, and
the kick-off role played by N Halliwell and J Coupland of Loughborough
Technical University, who organized a challenging meeting that served
to share scientific experience and consolidate personal friendships.
References
Barnhart D H, Adrian R J and Papen G C 1994 Phase conjugate holographic system for high
resolution particle image velocimetry Appl. Opt.33 7159–70
Coupland J (ed) 2003 Workshop on Holographic Metrology in Fluid Dynamics, Loughborough
CD-ROM Proceedings
Hinsch K D 2002 Holographic particle image velocimetry Meas. Sci. Technol.13 R61–72 (IOP Article)
Kompenhans J (ed) 2001 4th Int. Symp. on Particle Image Velocimetry, Göttingen CD-ROM Proceedings
Rood E P (ed) 1993 Holographic Particle Image Velocimetry (ASME FED 148) (New York: ASME)