In her article on the benefits of scientific collaboration between the sexes, Gina Hamilton cited Caroline Herschel's work with her brothers, William and John, as an example of a successful partnership (April pp 17–18). However, the John mentioned by Hamilton was [Johann] Alexander Herschel, whose contributions to astronomy were insignificant compared with those of William and Caroline. It was only with great reluctance that he helped them in their efforts to build ever-more powerful telescopes. Indeed, it would appear that anyone who entered the Herschel household vas dragooned into assisting in some way. For the record, William and his wife Mary also had a son called John, who later became a celebrated astronomer in his own tight.